Five-star nursing homes in South Dakota
21 nursing homes in South Dakota, 22% of the 96 there, have CMS's highest overall rating of 5 out of 5 in data processed on October 1, 2026. 12 of them also carry CMS's high-performing icon.
They are in 19 cities and towns and are listed by city in alphabetical order, not ranked. Another 15 homes have 4 out of 5. All nursing homes in South Dakota.
What five stars means
Nursing homes with 5 stars are considered to have much above average quality and nursing homes with 1 star are considered to have quality much below average.
No rating system can address all of the important considerations that go into a decision about which nursing home may be best for a particular person.
The overall rating starts from the health inspection rating, which CMS sets by comparing homes within the same state. How CMS calculates the ratings.
The 21 homes, by city
- The Neighborhoods at Brookview
Brookings, SD
Health inspections 5, staffing 4, quality measures 3. 79 certified beds.
CMS high-performing icon.
- Good Samaritan Society Canton
Canton, SD
Health inspections 5, staffing 4, quality measures 2. 56 certified beds.
- Estelline Nursing and Care Center
Estelline, SD
Health inspections 5, staffing 5, quality measures 5. 60 certified beds.
- Avera Eureka Health Care Center
Eureka, SD
Health inspections 4, staffing 5, quality measures 4. 56 certified beds.
- Faulkton Senior Living
Faulkton, SD
Health inspections 4, staffing 5, quality measures 4. 41 certified beds.
- Oakview Terrace
Freeman, SD
Health inspections 4, staffing 5, quality measures 5. 45 certified beds.
CMS high-performing icon.
- Good Samaritan Society Howard
Howard, SD
Health inspections 5, staffing 4, quality measures 4. 45 certified beds.
CMS high-performing icon.
- Avantara Lake Norden
Lake Norden, SD
Health inspections 4, staffing 4, quality measures 5. 50 certified beds.
- Menno-Olivet Care Center
Menno, SD
Health inspections 5, staffing 5, quality measures 2. 41 certified beds.
CMS high-performing icon.
- Avera Brady Health and Rehab
Mitchell, SD
Health inspections 5, staffing 5, quality measures 3. 84 certified beds.
CMS high-performing icon.
- Avera Maryhouse Long Term Care
Pierre, SD
Health inspections 5, staffing 5, quality measures 4. 80 certified beds.
CMS high-performing icon.
- Platte Care Center
Platte, SD
Health inspections 4, staffing 5, quality measures 2. 48 certified beds.
- Clarkson Health Care
Rapid City, SD
Health inspections 4, staffing 5, quality measures 4. 49 certified beds.
- Westhills Village Health Care Facility
Rapid City, SD
Health inspections 4, staffing 5, quality measures 5. 44 certified beds.
CMS high-performing icon.
- Good Samaritan Society Scotland
Scotland, SD
Health inspections 4, staffing 4, quality measures 5. 45 certified beds.
CMS high-performing icon.
- Walworth County Care Center, Inc
Selby, SD
Health inspections 5, staffing 4, quality measures 5. 50 certified beds.
CMS high-performing icon.
- Pioneer Memorial Nursing Home
Viborg, SD
Health inspections 5, staffing 4, quality measures 3. 46 certified beds.
CMS high-performing icon.
- Bethesda Home
Webster, SD
Health inspections 4, staffing 5, quality measures 4. 50 certified beds.
CMS high-performing icon.
- White River Health Care Center
White River, SD
Health inspections 4, staffing 5, quality measures 5. 52 certified beds.
CMS high-performing icon.
- Avera Sister James Care Center
Yankton, SD
Health inspections 4, staffing 5, quality measures 3. 194 certified beds.
- Sd Human Services Center - Geriatric Program
Yankton, SD
Health inspections 4, staffing 5, quality measures 2. 69 certified beds.
Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Provider Data Catalog, Provider Information. CMS processed this data on October 1, 2026 and this site copied it on November 22, 2026. It is a snapshot, not a live record: CMS updates ratings about once a month, and Medicare.gov Care Compare has the current ones. How this site uses the data.